Ladies and gentlemen of Gotham City: we have a new 007!
Of course, by the time you read this, Robert Pattinson’s casting as James Bond will be substantially old news, although (as of this writing) I’m surprised by how much discourse traction has spun out of the announcement nevertheless. Perhaps it was just nice to have something to talk about that wasn’t the total collapse of society.
Me? As From A To Bond will tell, I’m a lifelong Bond-head; but as for this project, honestly, I couldn’t care less. Villeneuve doesn’t seem like the guy; and Pattinson’s a fascinating actor when he’s allowed to be, but the choice feels too safe. Amazon is gross. (So are all the Silicon Valley-seized content farms IMHO, a pack of which Amazon MGM is squarely in the middle of “ewww.”)
But also, of late I’ve been getting my Bond elsewhere and utterly enjoying it — either in the Bond-free 007 novels by Kim Sherwood, of which I’ve written before; or the entirely-not-Bond Black Doves series on (yeah yeah, Silicon Valley) Netflix, which is like if James was a 40something wife and mother of two who’s a killer and a spy but also has emotional labour to do.
Actually, I think I like Black Doves most of all because it almost feels like (a more me-friendly) kind of romantasy, where the fantasy world is “spycraft.” Every one of the principal characters — particularly Ben Whishaw’s gorgeously sad-sack assassin Sam, but also Helen and Williams and even Reed (in series 2) — are so lost in their anguished loves, and the ways that those loves completely bork their ability to do their jobs effectively.
Or, they’re utterly amoral psychopaths like Eleanor or Laila or Dani, who love to get their fuck on almost as much as getting their gun on. I’m telling you, it’s a really fun brew.
Lord of Gifts
Less fun, less of a brew, is the stalwart The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, Amazon Content Farm’s continued attempt to become “a thing,” and a series which I both find enthralling (I have defended it rigorously in the past) and am pretty done with, as a project, nonetheless.
Something I’ve been thinking about a lot as Rings of Power spins out and The Hunt for Gollum spins up is how frankly idiotic it is that Hollywood has seized on Tolkien as a content license for blockbuster content. It’s… a pretty profound misreading of the source material. The most mainstream-friendly section of the story (The Lord of the Rings) has already been done, and even that had to be painstakingly reworked to resemble something like traditional, three-act-structure filmmaking.
Everything from there — even The Hobbit — is more and more squeeze to extract less or less juice. It’s also — this is the important part — less and less like what people think they’re getting when they hear the words “Middle-Earth.”
For example: most regular folk seem to think The Lord of the Rings is big, spectacular battles. That’s fair — the original trilogy had two of the best ever done.
But that’s… uh… it? Sure, there’s a third signature battle (of Five Armies) nearby in the legendarium; there’s also the Last Alliance of Elves and Men to which The Rings of Power is theoretically building, and the apocalyptic showdown in the First Age as told in The Silmarillion. But for the most part, Tolkien’s writing is not battleporn, at least in part because Tolkien hated combat, and used his writing to exorcise his wartime PTSD.
It’s funny that audiences complain when Middle-Earth projects are all singing and Elves, because — I swear to you, my dudes — that is what 90% of Tolkien’s writing is.
In any event, the Rings of Power team is making as good of a try at it as they can, but they’ve done away with the Hobbits this season, which really kills the fun of the show IMHO; and the sense of mystery and magic of the earlier seasons is fully gone, now that everyone is an Established Character heading towards a Known Outcome. It’s Star Trek: Strange New Worlds over here.
Probably the most important thing about the third season of the show, then, is that a giant sand vagina is the first thing to emerge from the desert of Mordor when Sauron builds his tower during the opening credits, which air every week.
Yes: every week, we watch the sandgina arise, form, become aroused, and eventually settle below Barad-dûr’s main gate. Sauron!! Stop thinking about her!


From A to Zygon

Survivor: Unlikeable Psychopath Season
Not since waayyyyyyy back in Vanuatu (season 9) has Survivor worked so very hard to make me stop watching the show. (And that time, they succeeded!) Ostensibly titled Survivor 51, the season currently airing is a casting failure as monumental as letting Coach back onto the show four times.
Now, normally, Survivor allows for one unlikeable psychopath per casting group. This isn’t a hard and fast rule: there isn’t always one; sometimes there are two; and some of them (Caroline Wiger, twisting forever in her mud net) turn out to be delightful in their way.
But broadly, I’d say any group of 18 castaways can withstand the inclusion of one person who, if you were to see them at the office Christmas party, you would leave the Christmas party before getting trapped talking to them.
The problem is the unlikeable part. I think the Survivor casting team (and Jeff “Probsty” Probst) think there’s some inherent TV theatrics waiting to happen in each one of these chronically dysregulated whackos — and hey, sometimes they’re right! Usually they’re wrong, though, so the decision — with Unlikeable Psychopath Season 51 — to stack the deck with seven of the monsters is basically a Brechtian exercise in seeing how unwatchable you can make your own show before your audience decides not to show up anymore.
As of this writing, there are 9 players left in Unlikeable Psychopath Season, and four of them are unlikeable psychopaths. We are facing a week where the cast might become fifty-fifty unlikeable psychopaths. They did this to themselves: I’ll see you at Survivor 52.
But hey, while we’re here:
Every Season of Survivor (That I’ve Seen), Ranked
1. Survivor: Australian Outback (Season 2)
Probably a sentimental fave more than an actual quality call, but I’ll always love this one most in my heart, so, here we are. And I had such a head-spinning crush on Elisabeth (I know, gross).
2. Survivor (Season 1)
Arguably should be #1. It’s still never been done better than this; the franchise has now spent 25 years (and counting) chasing the high of Richard Hatch climbing up a tree, observing his fellow castaways squabbling for a few minutes, and working out in real time exactly how one wins Survivor.
3. Survivor: Micronesia — Fans vs. Favourites (Season 16)
It doesn’t all come down to the Erik blindside, because I’d argue the Erik blindside isn’t as delectable as it is without all of the gameplay that leads up to it. But yes: Parvati, Cirie, Amanda and Natalie’s absolutely bizarre, almost witchcraft-esque bamboozlement of Erik remains one of the most incredible things I’ve ever seen on television in my life.
4. Survivor: David vs. Goliath (Season 37)
The one that brought me back. Nick’s turnaround from down-and-out loser to Sole Survivor was thrilling.
5. Survivor: Africa (Season 3)
Another sentimental favourite, but: Kenya remains the most live-wire dangerous environment the Survivor castaways were ever subjected to; this going on the air a couple weeks after 9/11 was weird and thorny in a way that I still remember; and Lex remains my favourite player of all time (and his loss by a fact-checking error in the castaway quiz continues to irritate me). I do miss the days when Survivor did the deep lore on the cultures they visited, even if that lore tended to be patronizing, colonial, and silly as hell.
6. Survivor: Palau (Season 10)
Yeah, turns out Steph is gross as hell. But her solo run on this season, the sole survivor of the worst tribe of all time, was inspired (and inspiring).
7. Survivor: All-Stars (Season 8)
Survivor’s first “event” season was just so much goddamned fun. Plus, Hatch wrestled a shark. I’m less sanguine about the fact that this season put an entire sexual assault on national television and treated it as a weird joke; but, Survivor seasons remain fascinating time capsules, if you can keep the bile down while thinking about them.
8. Survivor: Cook Islands (Season 13)
It is crazy that “the one where they divided the tribes by race” is also one of the best seasons they ever had, for reasons having nothing to do with the aforementioned decision to divide the tribes by race.
9. Survivor: Pearl Islands (Season 7)
I was deep in my pirate phase so this one came along at the exact right time. Casting an actual pirate (Rupert Boneham!) didn’t hurt.
10. Survivor: Marquesas (Season 4)
A pretty high-key season that couldn’t quite match its priors but still gave us Boston Rob, along with that pissing-on-the-hand thing, and the single most nauseating food challenge they’ve ever done.
11. Survivor 41 (Season 41)
IN THIS HOUSE WE LOVE AND RESPECT ERIKA. Also, when it was actually new, the “New Era” seemed… kinda great??
12. Survivor 42 (Season 42)
In this house we also love and respect Maryanne. Easily the best thing about the New Era was the degree to which it let people pull “The Nick Move” — commit potentially game-ending errors early in the game and then re-plot their strategy in real time to come out a winner. It’s beautiful when it works.
13. Survivor: China (Season 15)
I actually think I loved this one: Courtney’s pure, unbridled, (what we would now call) Gen Z Stare (I believe she’s technically a Millennial; watching these shows out of order is wild) just rocked, as did seeing her take out the disgusting Jean-Robert.
14. Survivor 48 (Season 48)
A deep bench of GREAT casting really livens up this season. You get Kyle/Kamilla AND Joe/Eva here and the whole season seems winsome.
15. Survivor: Winners at War (Season 40)
Kind of awesome, kind of not? I still don’t know who Tony Vlachos is or why I should care.
16. Survivor 45 (Season 45)
Casting, casting, casting. No one is actually named Dee, but I’ll accept the deception if it also gives us Emily Flippen.
17. Survivor: Samoa (Season 19)
Russel Hantz is a tricky one. He’s a likeable psychopath. He completely sucks and his broadly misogynistic gameplay is excruciating to watch… but with his stupid little hat and Stimpson J. Cat physique, he’s like some kind of god damned Mr. Mxyzptlk out there on those islands. I keep expecting him to wink and disappear in a puff of smoke.
18. Survivor 50: In the Hands of the Fans (Season 50)
Would probably rank higher if not for Rizo. And that utterly ungainly title. Devens’ coin-flip an absolute all-timer moment.
19. Survivor: Fiji (Season 14)
Yeah, I like this one. I like Earl.
20. Survivor: Panama (Season 12)
Not memorable, but it gave us Cirie, so.
21. Survivor: Edge of Extinction (Season 38)
Weird, provocative idea.
22. Survivor 47 (Season 47)
Rachel was pretty great but the gas is fully out of the car, re: “New Era” at this point.
23. Survivor: Gabon (Season 17)
A decent return to Africa but didn’t really net out much in the way of interesting players or gameplay. Still, it was pretty… and thankfully, the first to be shot in HD.
24. Survivor: Thailand (Season 5)
Gross as hell in retrospect (and also at the time).
25. Survivor 49 (Season 49)
Rizo is excruciating to watch and his perpetual repeat of his self-annointed mantra was TV poison. (Knowing in advance that he was coming back for season 50 made Survivor 50 seem like a profoundly unwelcome slog, which is not the kind of hype you want going into your anniversary show.) Savannah’s end-run makes up for Rizo a bit, at least.
26. Survivor 43 (Season 43)
Speaking of unlikeable psychopaths, Mike Gabler.
27. Survivor 44 (Season 44)
Or, Yam Yam.
28. Survivor 46 (Season 46)
Or the most dangerous warning sign re: Unlikeable Psychopath casting yet, Bhanu.
29. Survivor: Island of the Idols (Season 49)
I know most people hate this one and it’s NOT great, but those goofy idol heads of Sandra and Rob will never not make me laugh so I’ll rank it a bit higher than other folks might.
30. Survivor: The Amazon (Season 6)
Dull.
31. Survivor: Guatemala (Season 11)
A huge disappointment after its predecessor.
32. Survivor: Tocantins (Season 18)
The casting of Coach is the kind of unforced error you only get to to get away with once. That the loathsome creep being has been brought back four times, however, is a stain on the entire operation. He is emblematic of every single one of this series’ worst instincts. Unfortunately due to watch order, I had to endure this season right after watching Survivor 50 (also featuring Coach), and it nearly stopped me dead. I never want to see this man again. (If I keep filling in my Survivor gaps, I have two more seasons with him. Ghghghhh.)
33. Survivor: Vanuatu (Season 9)
At this point in my life I decided that Survivor had become boring and predictable so I dropped out. (I was wrong.)
34. Survivor: Unlikeable Psychopath Season (Season 51)
See above.
End notes
The most thrilling piece of news out of last week wasn’t the cascading failures of the world’s tech systems. It was the Wachowskis filing to terminate the copyright that Warner Brothers holds on The Matrix.
Now, this could be a simple case of the sisters teeing up a new licensing arrangement for an asset they no longer have (or want) any active involvement in. But in this new era (not the Survivor New Era; the Silicon Valley seizing studios era), I’m all for the Wachowskis doing anything and everything to put themselves in the best possible position re: the control of their signature franchise.
Meanwhile: if you want to think about the tech, the broligarchy, the system thinking of it all… you could scarcely do better than this Jon Stewart episode, re: The Nerd Reich. It’s wild stuff — it virtually invites a handwavey, “nah this is all just conspiracy nonsense” read — but as someone flying even marginally too close to that particular sun right now, I assure you: it’s very, very likely.
Stewart’s guest, Jon Durán, also makes what feels to me like this month’s most important point: the recent elections, in the U.S. and around the world, bring about a “window of reprieve,” and are not a solution or an end-state. It’s extremely dangerous to think that they are… almost as appealing as it is as to think that they are. (It might just be the circles I run in, but boy, older white ladies sure seem like they think they’re at the party on Coruscant right now.)
So, like, yes, it’s broadly encouraging that some common cause against fascism, billionaires, and data centres have all emerged; but we still have to eliminate the problem. More on this, perhaps, next week.
